Military dictatorship

A military dictatorship is a dictatorship in which the military exerts complete or substantial control over political authority, and the dictator is often a high-ranked military officer.

The reverse situation is to have civilian control of the military.

Creation and evolution

Most military dictatorships are formed after a coup d'état has overthrown the previous government. There have been cases, however, where the civilian government had been formally maintained but the military exercises de facto control—the civilian government is either bypassed or forced to comply with the military's wishes. For example, from 1916 until the end of World War I, the German Empire was governed as an effective military dictatorship, because its leading generals had gained such a level of control over Kaiser Wilhelm II that the Chancellor and other civilian ministers effectively served at their pleasure. Alternatively, the Empire of Japan after 1931 never in any formal way drastically altered the constitutional structure of its government, but from that point, it is typically seen as a military dictatorship, since the Army and Navy had the effective legal right to veto the formation of undesirable governments (and also to compel the resignation of an existing government that had lost their favor), and since key cabinet posts traditionally held by civilians (especially the Premiership) were instead filled by active flag officers.

Military dictatorships may gradually restore significant components of civilian government while the senior military commander still maintains executive political power. As an example, the Chilean military dictatorship under Augusto Pinochet conducted a plebiscite in 1980 that instituted a new constitution, thus legitimizing the regime's rule.

Justification

In the past, military juntas have justified their rule as a way of bringing political stability for the nation or rescuing it from the threat of "dangerous ideologies". For example, the threat of communism, socialism, and Islamism was often used. Military regimes tend to portray themselves as non-partisan, as a "neutral" party that can provide interim leadership in times of turmoil, and also tend to portray civilian politicians as corrupt and ineffective. One of the almost universal characteristics of a military government is the institution of martial law or a permanent state of emergency.

Comparison with other forms of authoritarianism

Comparison with monarchies

A military dictatorship is distinct from an absolute monarchy, although there are some similarities, especially concerning how the two are (or historically have been) established. Virtually all absolute monarchs (and even most constitutional monarchs) are commanders-in-chief of their nations' militaries, wear military uniforms at least on a ceremonial basis and hold military ranks and/or titles. Also, senior members of royal families, especially if they are male and/or heirs apparent or presumptive, are expected to perform military service prior to ascending the throne. Moreover, almost all monarchies (both current and defunct) established themselves over the past centuries and millennia by force of arms. A key difference between a monarchy and a military dictatorship is that once they are established and recognized by their subjects (a process that has often taken many generations) a monarchy typically establishes some form of hereditary succession to legitimately transfer power from generation to generation, and while there historically have been many cases of disputed claims to a throne, attempting to seize power through sheer force of arms without some sort of credible hereditary claim is usually regarded as illegitimate and/or illegal by monarchists. In constitutional monarchies the monarch is usually the commander-in-chief and is often formally the highest-ranking military officer but in practice is expected to defer to the advice of civilian ministers, especially when appointing flag officers who will exercise actual operational command, thus maintaining civilian control of the military.

On the other hand, modern military dictatorships typically eschew hereditary succession with long-lasting juntas often emphasizing the traditional methods of promotion within the officer ranks as the eventual path to civil power. Military dictatorships which have attempted to establish themselves as monarchies or otherwise implement hereditary succession, whether or not by attempting to establish themselves as monarchies, have often collapsed very quickly. In one example, Oliver Cromwell after deposing and executing King Charles I of England refused all offers to take the English Crown, but nevertheless attempted to have power transferred after his death to his son Richard Cromwell; however, the younger Cromwell lacked the respect or support of the English military establishment, and was thus quickly forced to relinquish power. In another, a few years after staging a coup and establishing himself as the French First Republic's dictator, Napoleon Bonaparte crowned himself French Emperor. Although he subsequently married a Habsburg princess and sired an heir to his newly established throne, Napoleon's claim to power was never fully accepted by French royalists who supported the deposed House of Bourbon, nor by other European monarchies. Eventually, Napoleon's armies were defeated and he was forced to abdicate and go into exile. Although Napoleon's nephew eventually re-established the Bonapartist monarchy for a time, his seizure of power might be better described in the context of a civilian dictatorship as described in the next section.

Comparison with civilian dictatorship

A military dictatorship is also different from civilian dictatorship for a number of reasons: their motivations for seizing power, the institutions through which they organize their rule and the ways in which they leave power. Often viewing itself as saving the nation from the corrupt or myopic civilian politicians, a military dictatorship justifies its position as "neutral" arbiters on the basis of their membership within the armed forces, which in many countries are nominally expected to be apolitical institutions. For example, many juntas adopt titles along the lines of "Committee of National Restoration", or "National Liberation Committee". Military leaders often rule as a junta, selecting one of themselves as a head.[1]

Current cases of Military Dictatorships

CountryPast governmentDate adoptedLeading event
 Thailand[note 1][2]Unitary parliamentary constitutional monarchyMay 22, 20142014 Thai coup d'état
 SudanFederal dominant-party presidential republicApril 11, 20192019 Sudanese coup d'état
2021 Sudanese coup d'état
 MaliUnitary semi-presidential republicAugust 19, 20202020 Malian coup d'état
2021 Malian coup d'état
 MyanmarUnitary assembly-independent republicFebruary 1, 20212021 Myanmar coup d'état
 ChadUnitary dominant-party presidential republicApril 20, 20212021 Northern Chad offensive
 GuineaUnitary presidential republicSeptember 5, 20212021 Guinean coup d'état
 Burkina FasoUnitary semi-presidential republicJanuary 24, 20222022 Burkinabé coup d'état

Former cases

Country names in bold are ones that are currently a military dictatorship.

Africa

Mengistu Haile Mariam, Aman Mikael Andom and Atnafu Abate, leaders of the Ethiopian military junta
  1.  Algeria (1965–1976; 1992–1994; 2019)
  2.  Benin (1963–1964; 1965–1968; 1969–1970; 1972–1990)
  3.  Burkina Faso (1966–1980; 1980–1982; 1982–1983; 1983–1987; 1987–2014; 2015; 2022–present)
  4.  Burundi (1966–1974; 1976–1979; 1987–1992)
  5.  Central African Republic (1966–1979; 1981–1986; 2003–2005; 2013–2014)
  6.  Chad (1975–1979; 1982–1990; 2021–present)
  7.  Ciskei (1990–1994)
  8.  Comoros (1999–2006)
  9.  Republic of the Congo (1968–1969; 1977–1979)
  10.  Côte d'Ivoire (1999–2000)
  11.  Egypt (1953–1956; 1981–2011; 2011–2012; 2014–2018)
  12. Ethiopia Ethiopia (1974–1987)
  13.  The Gambia (1994–1996)
  14.  Ghana (1966–1969; 1972–1975; 1975–1979; 1981–1993)
  15.  Guinea (1984–1990; 2008–2010; 2021–present)
  16.  Guinea-Bissau (1980–1984; 1999; 2003; 2012)
  17.  Lesotho (1986–1991; 1991–1993)
  18.  Liberia (1980–1986)
  19. Libya Libya (1969–2011)
  20.  Madagascar (1972–1976)
  21.  Mali (1968–1992; 2012; 2020, 2021–present)
  22.  Mauritania (1978–1979; 1979–1992; 2005–2007; 2008–2009)
  23.  Niger (1974–1987; 1987–1993; 1996–1999; 2010–2011)
  24. Nigeria Nigeria (1966; 1966–1975; 1975–1976; 1976–1979; 1983–1985; 1985–1993; 1993–1998; 1998–1999)
  25.  Rwanda (1973–1994)
  26.  São Tomé and Príncipe (1995; 2003)
  27.  Sierra Leone (1967–1968; 1992–1996; 1997–1998)
  28.  Somalia (1969–1976; 1980–1991)
  29.  Sudan (1958–1964; 1969–1971; 1985–1986; 1989–1993; 2019–present)
  30.  Togo (1967–2005)
  31.  Transkei (1987–1994)
  32.  Uganda (1971–1979; 1985–1986)
  33.  Venda (1990–1994)
  34.  Zaire (1965–1997)
  35.  Zimbabwe (2017–2018)

Americas

Augusto Pinochet, who ruled Chile from 1973 to 1990.
  1.  Argentina (1835–1852; 1930–1932; 1943–1946; 1955–1958; 1966–1973; 1976–1983)
  2.  Bolivia (1839–1843; 1848; 1857–1861; 1861; 1864–1871; 1876–1879; 1899; 1920–1921; 1930–1931; 1936–1940; 1943–1946; 1951–1952; 1964–1982)
  3.  Brazil (1889–1891; 1891–1894; 1930; 1937-1945; 1964–1985)
  4.  Chile (1924–1925; 1925; 1927–1931; 1932; 1973–1990)
  5.  Colombia (1854; 1953–1958)
  6.  Costa Rica (1868–1870; 1876–1882; 1917–1919)
  7.  Cuba (1933; 1952–1959)
  8.  Dominican Republic (1882–1899; 1930–1961; 1963–1965)
  9.  Ecuador (1876–1883;1925–1926;1935–1938; 1947; 1963–1966; 1972–1979; 2000)
  10.  El Salvador (1885–1911; 1931–1979; 1979–1982)
  11.  Guatemala (1931–1944; 1944–1945; 1954–1957; 1957–1966; 1970–1986)
  12.  Grenada (1979-1983)
  13.  Haiti (1946; 1950–1956; 1956–1957; 1986–1990; 1991–1994)
  14.  Honduras (1933–1949; 1956–1957; 1963–1971; 1972–1982; 2009–2010)
  15.  Mexico (1835–1846; 1913–1914)
  16.  Nicaragua (1937–1979)
  17.  Panama (1903–1904; 1968–1989)
  18.  Paraguay (1940–1948; 1954–1989)
  19.  Peru (1843–1844; 1865–1868; 1868–1872; 1879–1881; 1914–1915; 1930–1933; 1933–1939; 1948–1956; 1962–1963; 1968–1980)
  20.  Suriname (1980–1991)
  21.  Uruguay (1865–1868; 1876–1879; 1933–1938; 1973–1985)
  22.  Venezuela (1858–1859; 1861–1863; 1863–1868; 1869–1870; 1892–1898; 1899–1908; 1908–1935; 1948–1958)

Asia

Indonesia's President Suharto in 1968
Thailand's Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha in 2014
  1. Afghanistan Afghanistan (1978)
  2.  Bangladesh (1975–1981; 1982–1990)
  3.  Cambodia (1970-1975; 1997-1999)
  4. China China /  Taiwan (189–192; 1915–1916; 1927–1928; 1928–1948; 1932–1945; 1948–1991)
  5. Military Flag of Goguryeo (Ssangyeongchong).svg Goguryeo (642–665; 665; 665–668)
  6. Goryeo Goryeo (1170–1270)
  7.  Indonesia (1966–1998)
  8.  Iran (1925–1941; 1953–1955; 1978–1979)
  9.  Iraq (1933–1935; 1936; 1937–1938; 1941; 1949–1950; 1952–1953; 1958–1963; 1963–1968; 1968–1979)
  10.  Japan (1192–1867;[3]1931-1940; 1940-1945)
  11.  South Korea (1961–1963; 1963–1972; 1972–1979; 1981–1987)
  12.  Laos (1959–1960)
  13.  Lebanon (1988–1990)
  14.  Myanmar (1962–1988; 1988–2011; 2021–present)
  15. Nepal Nepal (1776–1777; 1776–1779; 1777–1778; 1782–1785; 1785–1804; 1806–1837; 1838-1840; 1840-1846; 1846–1951)
  16.  North Yemen (1962–1967; 1974–1977; 1977–1978; 1978; 1978–1990)
  17.  Pakistan (1958–1969; 1969–1971; 1977–1988; 1999–2008)
  18.  Philippines (1898; 1943–1945; 1972–1981)
  19.  South Vietnam (1963–1967)
  20.  Syria (1949; 1951–1954; 1963–1970, 1970–2000)
  21.  Tajikistan (1992-1997)
  22.  Thailand (1933–1938; 1938–1944; 1948–1957; 1947; 1959–1963; 1963–1973; 1976; 1977; 1977–1979; 1991; 2006; 2006–2008; 2014–present)[2]
  23.  Vietnam (1533–1789; 1558–1788)
  24.  Yemen (1990–2012)

Europe

Spanish leader Francisco Franco in 1975
  1.  Albania (1925–1939)
  2.  Azerbaijan (1993–1994)
  3.  Bulgaria (1923–1926; 1934–1935; 1944–1946)
  4.  Cyprus (1974)
  5.  France (1799–1814; 1848; 1851–1858; 1870–1871)
  6.  Georgia (1992)
  7.  Germany (1916–1918)
  8.  Great Britain (1653–1659)
  9.  Greece (1909–1910; 1922; 1922; 1922-1924; 1925–1926; 1933; 1935; 1935–1941; 1967–1974)
  10.  Hungary (1849)
  11.  Montenegro (1913–1915; 1915-1916; 1917)
  12.  Poland (1926–1935; 1981–1983)
  13.  Portugal (1915; 1917–1918; 1926–1933; 1974–1975)
  14.  Romania (1941–1944)
  15. Russia (1918–1920)
  16.  San Marino (1957)
  17.  Spain (1923–1930; 1936–1975)
  18.  Turkey (1913-1918; 1960–1961; 1971-1973; 1980–1983)
  19.  Two Sicilies (1860)
  20.  Ukraine (1649–1764; 1918)

Oceania

  1.  Fiji (1987–1999; 2006–2014)

See also

Notes

  1. ^ Junta formally dissolved in 2019

Source

  1. ^ Cheibub, José Antonio; Gandhi, Jennifer; Vreeland, James Raymond (1 April 2010). "Democracy and dictatorship revisited". Public Choice. 143 (1–2): 67–101. doi:10.1007/s11127-009-9491-2. ISSN 0048-5829. S2CID 45234838.
  2. ^ a b
  3. ^ "Shogunate". britannica.com. Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. Retrieved 13 June 2020. The shogunate was the hereditary military dictatorship of Japan (1192-1867).

Media files used on this page

Flag of Thailand.svg
The national flag of Kingdom of Thailand since September 2017; there are total of 3 colours:
  • Red represents the blood spilt to protect Thailand’s independence and often more simply described as representing the nation.
  • White represents the religion of Buddhism, the predominant religion of the nation
  • Blue represents the monarchy of the nation, which is recognised as the centre of Thai hearts.
Flag of the Central African Republic.svg
The proportions of this flag are 3:2; however, there is no official definition for the correct proportions and also 5:3 is widely used.
Flag of Côte d'Ivoire.svg
Flag of the Ivory Coast, written by Jon Harald Søby, modified by Zscout370. The colors match to what is reported at http://fotw.vexillum.com/flags/ci.html.
Flag of Sao Tome and Principe.svg
Flag of São Tomé and Príncipe
Flag of Brazil (1968–1992).svg
Flag of Brazil (1968-1992)
Flag of Chile.svg
It is easy to put a border around this flag image
Flag of the Dominican Republic.svg
The flag of the Dominican Republic has a centered white cross that extends to the edges. This emblem is similar to the flag design and shows a bible, a cross of gold and 6 Dominican flags. There are branches of olive and palm around the shield and above on the ribbon is the motto "Dios,Patria!, Libertad" ("God, Country, Freedom") and to amiable freedom. The blue is said to stand for liberty, red for the fire and blood of the independence struggle and the white cross symbolized that God has not forgotten his people. "Republica Dominicana". The Dominican flag was designed by Juan Pablo Duarte, father of the national Independence of Dominican Republic. The first dominican flag was sewn by a young lady named Concepción Bona, who lived across the street of El Baluarte, monument where the patriots gathered to fight for the independence, the night of February 27th, 1844. Concepción Bona was helped by her first cousin María de Jesús Pina.
Flag of Haiti.svg
The national and official state flag of Haiti; arms obtained from http://www.webchantier.com/. The civil flag can be found at here.
Flag of Mexico.svg
Flag of Mexico Official version of the Flag of the United Mexican States or Mexico, adopted September 16th 1968 by Decree (Published August 17th 1968), Ratio 4:7. The previous version of the flag displayed a slightly different Coat of Arms. It was redesigned to be even more resplendent due to the upcoming Mexico City 1968 Olympic Games; According to Flag of Mexico, the colors are Green Pantone 3425 C and Red Pantone 186 C. According to [1] or [2], that translates to RGB 206, 17, 38 for the red, and RGB 0, 104, 71 for the green.
State flag of Iran (1964–1980).svg
New Version of :Image:Lionflag.svg with a cleaner emblem and the correct ratio.
Flag of Iraq (1963–1991).svg
Flag of Iraq, 1963-1991. Also flag of Syria, 1963-1972.
Flag of Japan (1870-1999).svg
Variant version of a flag of Japan, used between 1870 and 1999 (aspect ratio 7:10).
Flag of Japan (1870–1999).svg
Variant version of a flag of Japan, used between 1870 and 1999 (aspect ratio 7:10).
Flag of Laos (1952-1975).svg
Flag of the Kingdom of Laos between 1952 - 1975.
Flag of Laos (1952–1975).svg
Flag of the Kingdom of Laos between 1952 - 1975.
Flag of Syria.svg
It is easy to put a border around this flag image
Flag of France (1794–1815, 1830–1958).svg
Author/Creator: unknown, Licence: PD
Flag of the German Empire.svg
Bundesflagge und Handelsflagge des Norddeutschen Bundes (1866-1871) und Reichsflagge des Deutschen Reiches (1871-1918)
Flag of Germany (1867–1918).svg
Bundesflagge und Handelsflagge des Norddeutschen Bundes (1866-1871) und Reichsflagge des Deutschen Reiches (1871-1918)
Flag of Portugal.svg
Flag of Portugal, created by Columbano Bordalo Pinheiro (1857-1929), officially adopted by Portuguese government in June 30th 1911 (in use since about November 1910). Color shades matching the RGB values officially reccomended here. (PMS values should be used for direct ink or textile; CMYK for 4-color offset printing on paper; this is an image for screen display, RGB should be used.)
Flag of Spain (1945–1977).svg
Author/Creator: SanchoPanzaXXI, Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0
Flag of Spain during the Spanish State. It was adopted on 11 October 1945 with Reglamento de Banderas Insignias y Distintivos (Flags, Ensigns and Coats of Arms Bill)
Flag of Fiji.svg
Author/Creator: unknown, Licence: CC0
Augusto Pinochet foto oficial coloreada.jpg
Author/Creator: The author of the original file is: Ministerio de Relaciones Exteriores de Chile
The photo was colored by Janitoalevic
The original file was uploaded by Sfs90, Licence: CC BY 2.0 cl
Official portrait of Augusto Pinochet Ugarte (colored)
Prins Bernhard in Zaire (voorheen Belgisch Congo), Prins Bernhard reikt Presiden, Bestanddeelnr 926-6031.jpg
Author/Creator: Rob Mieremet / Anefo, Licence: CC0
Collectie / Archief : Fotocollectie Anefo

Reportage / Serie : [ onbekend ]
Beschrijving : Prins Bernhard in Zaire (voorheen Belgisch Congo), Prins Bernhard reikt President Mobutu van Zaire Orde van de Gouden Ark uit
Datum : 12 augustus 1973
Locatie : Zaïre
Trefwoorden : onderscheidingen, presidenten, prinsen
Persoonsnaam : Bernhard, prins
Fotograaf : Mieremet, Rob / Anefo
Auteursrechthebbende : Nationaal Archief
Materiaalsoort : Negatief (zwart/wit)
Nummer archiefinventaris : bekijk toegang 2.24.01.03

Bestanddeelnummer : 926-6031
Flag of Georgia (1990–2004).svg
Flag of Georgia used from 1990 to 2004, with slightly different proportions than the 1918 to 1921 flag.
Military Flag of Goguryeo (Ssangyeongchong).svg
Author/Creator: Samhanin, Licence: CC0
Military Flag of Goguryeo (Ssangyeongchong, the end of the 5th century)
Flag of Hungary (1915-1918, 1919-1946).svg
Flag of Hungary from 6 November 1915 to 29 November 1918 and from August 1919 until mid/late 1946.
Flag of Ecuador (1900–2009).svg
Made by author of Xramp, first uploaded by Denelson83 as Flag of Ecuador.svg, modifications by Husunqu.
Flag of Lesotho (1987-2006).svg
Flag of Lesotho 1987-2006
Flag of Rwanda (1962–2001).svg
The former flag of Rwanda (1962-2001). Commonly refered to as the "R" flag.
Francisco Franco 1975 (cropped).jpg
Author/Creator: Fotograaf Onbekend / Anefo, Licence: CC0
Francisco Franco 1975
Flag of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies (1816).svg
It is easy to put a border around this flag image
Derg.gif
Leading members of the Derg; Mengistu Haile Mariam, Teferi Bante and Atnafu Abate.
Flag of the Commonwealth (1658-1660).svg
Flag of the Protectorate (Commonwealth of England, Scotland and Ireland) between 1658 and 1660.
Royal flag of Goryeo (Bong-gi).svg
Royal Flag of the Goryeo dynasty. Flag's name is "Phoenix flag" ( hanja: 鳳旗, 봉기, Bong-gi). This flag is in the War Memorial of Korea.
Flag of Nepal (1743–1962).svg
Author/Creator: Orange Tuesday, Licence: CC BY-SA 3.0
19世紀~1962年のネパール国旗 [1]
Flag of Ethiopia (1975–1987).svg
Flag of Ethiopia (1975–1987)
Flag of Albania (1934–1939).svg
Flag of the Kingdom of Albania (1928 - 1939)
Jenderal TNI Soeharto.png
General Suharto as President and Armed Forces Commander
Flag of San Marino (1862–2011).svg
The flag of San Marino, before the 2011 standardization
Flag of Greece (1970-1975).svg
Flag of Greece (1970–1975), adopted by the Greek military Junta; Aspect ratio: 7:12
Flag of Afghanistan (1978–1980).svg
Flag of Afghanistan from 1978 to 1980. Includes emblem File:Emblem of Afghanistan (1978-1980).svg with the name of the "Khalq" faction of the People's Democratic Party of Afghanistan as its central element.
Chan o cha Portrait.jpg
Prime Minister Chan-o-cha
Flag of Iraq (1963–1991); Flag of Syria (1963–1972).svg
Flag of Iraq, 1963-1991. Also flag of Syria, 1963-1972.